Democratic incumbent Josh Kaul holds a strong position in the 2026 Wisconsin Attorney General race due to his established record and forecasts projecting a lean-Democratic outcome with roughly a nine-point margin. The November 3 election features a rematch against Republican challenger Eric Toney, who has secured endorsements from over 75 percent of the state's sheriffs while criticizing Kaul's handling of crime lab backlogs and forensic testing delays. Recent debates have centered on these operational issues, federal lawsuits against the Trump administration, and statewide crime trends, with Kaul highlighting reductions in violent crime. Trader consensus reflects incumbency advantages and historical down-ballot patterns in the state despite the 2024 presidential results.